Previous Entry | Next Entry

Green Lantern

lightning redirection (Iroh/Avatar)
This weekend I watched Green Lantern at my local theater. It's not the movie to end all superhero movies, but it did a few things most reviews seemed to skip over, which I thought were worth pointing out.

I read several critical reviews before I saw this, which complained (among other things) that this was just like all of the other superhero movies we'd seen before: We get the introduction to Our Hero as a normal guy, we see his job and his prowess with the ladies, we see how he gets his powers and how he learns to use them, and things quickly build up to a boss fight with the fate of something important at stake. As a Troper, I know that Tropes Are Not Bad, so I will not be quick to criticize a movie for using a standard Three Act Structure. While the movie does use a standard superhero-film template, it does what it does well, I think.

[SPOILERS from this point out] One of the things I was particularly impressed by was that they made the hero's character development explicitly essential to the plot. If Hal Jordan doesn't overcome his fear, Earth and the universe are doomed. And I particularly respected the way they had him overcome that fear. I've watched far too many anime where everything the hero accomplishes is done through sheer heroic willpower. Willpower is essential in this story, but it's not enough. Hal Jordan has tried all his life to be the fearless hero he saw his father as, and his fear of commitment and success has beaten him every time. And finally, right before the climax, he sits down with the people whom he loves and respects most in the world, and he confesses his fear and inadequacy, and they look him in the eye and tell him "You're not fearless, but you are courageous. Just like your father was." This is not some cheesy, one-size-fits-all "You can do it! We believe in you!" This is a personal statement of affirmation, based on long-term, intimate knowledge of the man behind the mask. If it hadn't been true, if it hadn't resonated and rung his soul like a giant gong, it wouldn't have worked.

And boy did it work. It changed the man on the most fundamental level. It made him fearless.

And fearlessness was exactly what was needed. In the ensuing battle, still ringing with the power of that soul-deep affirmation from the people who know him best, Hal Jordan shows us what fearlessness really looks like.

It couldn't have happened without the ones close to him. If Hal's sister had kept her mouth shut, if she'd stumbled over her words and failed to look him in the eye, if she'd distanced herself from him over the previous decades and prioritized other things over learning to understand her brother, Parallax would have shredded him and then everyone else. Hal Jordan is not the only hero in this movie.

This is why superhero movies are worth making and worth watching. If they're just flights of fancy, they're superfluous. But stories that teach us about the things that really matter: that is valuable.

That's why I liked Green Lantern.

Comments

( 3 comments — Leave a comment )
(Anonymous)
Jun. 27th, 2011 03:29 pm (UTC)
"You're not fearless, but you are courageous."
Hi, saw this first on TV Tropes. You make good points, but are you sure about that quote? Elsewhere it's claimed that the line is "You have courage because you are courageous." (Exact words or not, that's the gist anyway.)I rather doubt it, no writer is that stupid or willfully dense. But that probable misquote has spread across the internet, thanks to Twitter, etc.
computersherpa
Jun. 27th, 2011 06:10 pm (UTC)
Re: "You're not fearless, but you are courageous."
The quote isn't exact--I was paraphrasing. No idea about what's been said elsewhere. :-)
m_ichka
Jul. 4th, 2011 12:14 am (UTC)
The Gifts of Imperfection (Brene Brown)
I am struck by the fact that your description of what Jordan does at the crucial moment -- confessing to trusted friends his fear and inadequacy -- opened the door to courage and a whole-hearted life. I'm reading an amazing book right now (see the subject line of this post) which takes that whole idea and unpacks it... it is truly an amazing book, and I am learning so much, both about why some things I naturally do are healthy for me, and why I need to grow in other areas. If you want to get a short video overview of the book, check out this link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X4Qm9cGRub0
That's what I'm learning this week :-)
RH
( 3 comments — Leave a comment )

Profile

Mage Power (Denki/RoI)
computersherpa
Horizons ever brighter

Latest Month

October 2011
S M T W T F S
      1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031     

Favorite sites

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Tiffany Chow